Find Research
Our World View
Industry Perspectives
Research Program
Parallax View Magazine
> stay tuned
View our collections of research around key subject areas:
X-Factory--Part One
A Paradigm for Smart Connected Factories

X-Factory is a demonstration factory (making real products) created by PTC to help manufacturers visualize a path to the Smart Factory. Here we describe what makes a factory smart and get a look at the engineering, material handling, and chassis manufacturing stages.

Full Article Below -
Untitled Document

( This article is excerpted from the complimentary report:
X-Factory: A Paradigm for Smart Connected Factories
, available for download here. )

What Makes a Factory Smart?

The way we manufacture goods, and the very nature of the factories producing them, are going through profound changes. The world’s major economies have all recognized the need to rapidly evolve their manufacturing capabilities, as reflected in Germany’s Industrie 4.0, Made in China 2025 (MIC 2025), and the more loosely defined ‘smart factory’ concept in North America. Key components of this transformation include:

  • Physical-Digital Systems—Smart connected machines and systems form the core of manufacturing, transportation, and distribution systems.
  • Autonomous Collaborating Production and Logistics Equipment—Production machines, logistics equipment, and their systems operate autonomously, communicating and coordinating with each other at different levels in a hierarchy; e.g. a welding station coordinates several welding arms, precisely synchronized with the conveyor system, driven by chassis-specific instructions; each stage of production synchronized with the next; guided by production scheduling, transportation optimization, inventory levels, and ultimately by end demand.
  • Personalization and Mass-Customization—The ability to do short runs, or ‘runs of one’ with the same efficiencies and costs as large runs. Mechanisms for end customers to easily visualize, personalize, and configure the options they want.
  • Agile Design and Manufacturing Processes—The ability to frequently and incrementally adjust and improve the design of a product and manufacturing processes.
  • Visibility and Coordination Across Value Chains—Each smart factory is a ‘team player,’ integrating across the smart digital supply chains it participates in. Precise visibility is shared across nodes of production, transport, and distribution, which can then be co-optimized, not isolated.
  • Automation of Routine Tasks/Human-Machine Fusion—Machines can’t do it all alone. The next generation factory optimizes and unifies the roles of the people, the machinery, and the intelligence uniting them. People are freed from repetitive, dangerous, and injury-prone work to work on processes and tasks where they add the most value. Human Machine Interfaces become increasingly seamless, intuitive, and integrated with factory workers (e.g. via wearables such as smart glasses and smart gloves).
  • Participative Work Design and Learning—Front line workers are empowered with knowledge, authority, and trust to constantly improve the manufacturing processes, and are provided with the tools to continuously learn and progress professionally.
  • On-going Resource Efficiency Improvement—Incentives, tools, and systems are in place to continually reduce materials and energy use.
  • Safety and Security—Architecture, design, policies, training, and testing ensure data is protected, hackers can’t subvert machines, and employees can work safely side-by-side with autonomous machines.

Translating this grand vision into reality has many challenges. Manufacturers are saddled with existing brownfield factories with various levels of automation, autonomy, and smart factory capabilities. The challenges in visualizing the possibilities and figuring out where to start in retrofitting existing facilities can slow down the pace of adoption. PTC decided to help by doing, rather than talking. With a number of partners, they have put together a demonstration factory, building real products, to provide a paradigm to help manufacturers imagine what is possible. They call it the X-Factory.

The Product: Sigma Tile

Figure 1 - Sigma Tile with Cover Off

The X-Factory is a demonstration factory, but making a real product, the PTC Sigma Tile, which is a low-cost IoT device that can be used for demonstration or IoT application development and testing. The hexagonal shaped device contains a Raspberry Pi 3 processor, with a Sense HAT (with sensors for temperature, humidity, pressure, acceleration, and orientation/gyroscope), an LED digital display, and USB and Ethernet connections. The device is built from off-the-shelf components such as the Raspberry Pi PCBs, sensors, display, and connectors, in a custom designed 3D-printed chassis.

The Factory: X-Factory Stages and Work Cells

The X-Factory was set up at LiveWorx 2018 in Boston and members of the public were encouraged to experience it first hand by performing some of the steps in the assembly and testing operations of the factory. The X-Factory is now being featured at PTC’s Customer Experience Center (CxC). There are six stages (stations) in the X-Factory: 1) Engineering and Design, 2) Chassis and Cover Manufacturing, 3) Assembly, 4) Testing and Packaging, 5) Warehouse, and 6) Production Management. Across these are 13 applications, all built on ThingWorx, running at the edge in an HPE Server. In addition, the factory included an autonomous robot doing automated material handling between the various work cells.

Engineering and Design

The engineering and design station of the X-Factory includes Creo (PTC’s parametric 3D solid-modeling CAD system) with simulation capabilities to help engineers test out different solutions to issues that arise. The use of 3D printing further allows mechanical designs to be prototyped and tried out rapidly. These proved their worth during the deployment of the X-Factory. At one point the specifications of the printed circuit board (PCB) in the Sigma Tile changed slightly which made the connection between the Sense HAT board and the Raspberry Pi board slightly looser, resulting in intermittent failures in quality assurance (QA) tests. Engineers used Creo to add a small ‘bumper’ onto the cover, which applied pressure on the connector. This succeeded in making the connection reliable, but caused the cover to lift up slightly. Engineers changed the solid bumper to a flexible spring, used Creo’s topology optimization to design just the right amount of pressure—enough to keep the connection reliable without lifting up the cover. With the 3D printers, they were able to rapidly iterate through these prototypes to arrive at a final design.

Automated Material Handling

At LiveWorx 2018, the movement of materials between each of the work stations or cells was handled by a HIROTEC Mobile Robot consisting on an OTTO 1500 self-driving vehicle with a Yaskawa Motoman dual-arm manipulator. Each station has two sets of gravity-fed rolling rack transfer stations: one set for input materials, the other for output materials. The autonomous self-guided robot carried small blue bins of parts or finished goods from the output racks of one station to the input racks of another. These racks are outfitted with sensors that drive an automated Kanban-like approach to production. The removal of a bin from an input rack or addition of a bin to an output rack can trigger the robot to come resupply inputs to or remove outputs from each station.

Figure 2 - HIRIOTEC Robot Transferring Materials Between Work Cells in the X-Factory at LiveWorx 2018

Chassis and Cover Manufacturing

The chassis and cover manufacturing station is a Formlabs Form Cell, which has five Form 2 3D printers,1 automated post-processing, and a robotic gantry system. As soon as each piece has been created by a 3D printer, the gantry system moves it to the post-processing unit for support removal and washing, and then to the output rolling rack transfer station where gravity feeds the finished units to the back of the station. They are positioned to be picked up by the HIROTEC’s Mobile Robot which delivers them to the assembly work cell.

Figure 3 - 3D Printing Station at LiveWorx 2018

The Expanding Role of 3D Printing in Manufacturing

While 3D printing will not replace injection molding for high-volume manufacturing soon, it is playing an important and rapidly evolving role in manufacturing:

  • Rapid Prototyping—3D printed prototypes get the kinks out before committing to high volume production. Com­­bined with simulation, this enables agile engineer­ing and manufacturing.
  • Personalized Parts/Products—3D is ideal for custom­ized parts, such as dental splints and dentures, surgical guides, prosthetics, custom jewelry, custom shoes, and custom glasses; all custom fitted to the individual.
  • Generative Design—In special situations, such as in aircraft where weight reduction is extremely valuable, generative design can be used to glean further weight reductions with optimized designs that can only be manufactured on a 3D printer.
  • Spare Parts—Especially useful for slow moving, expensive, or out-of-production parts.
  • Short Run Production—3D printing may be suitable for short runs, such as X-Factory. This can include field testing products before committing to high volumes.
  • Tooling—3D printing is being used to create soft tooling during production ramp. This is a rapid, lower risk approach—tooling costs are much lower, turnaround faster, and mistakes less dis­astrous. Manufacturers then transition to hard tooling for higher volumes.

 As the cost of 3D printing continues to drop, capabilities continue to rise, and the ability to do volume production increases, we see a continual increase in the dividing point (number of units) at which 3D printing makes sense. 

3D printing is not suitable for all manufacturing (see side bar). However, it was a good fit for X-factory, especially at this stage where they are producing low volumes. 3D printing supports the rapid development and iterative refinement of the product and processes. Just in getting ready for demonstrating at LiveWorx, they went through several iterations of the design, serving as a good example of how agile development dovetails with agile manufacturing.

The 3D printing station has a dashboard showing the status of each printer (idle/starting/printing/finished, which part is being printed, print time remaining, etc.); status of the post-processing machine, gantry, and transfer module; and controls to configure, calibrate, and control the subsystems within the Form Cell. While the machine can be entirely controlled through this panel, larger shops will typically control the station via an MES system. PTC’s strategy is to work with existing MES systems, rather than forcing customers to ‘rip and replace.’

Figure 4 - Temporary Supports on Sigma Tile Cover

As with most 3D printers, overhanging features need to be temporarily supported from underneath so that they don’t fall down when each subsequent layer is printed. Figure 4 shows the Sigma Tile cover with supports. Form Labs provides software that automatically add the needed supports.

In Part Two of this series, we will look at the assembly, testing and packaging, warehouse, production management, and solution integration for X-Factory.


1 These are stereolithography (SLA) printers that use a laser to cure a liquid photopolymer resin into solid isotropic parts, one layer at a time. SLA has the advantage of requiring less post processing than some other 3D printing techniques.-- Return to article text above

To view other articles from this issue of the brief, click here.

MarketViz powered.